4 Comments
User's avatar
John Vanatta's avatar

It seems likely the difference was in the expectation of an attack. There was no OODA loop to progress through. They had already decided their course of action. As shown in the first study, many officers will hesitate to shoot, whether it is a failure or delay to recognize what is happening, or a hesitancy to shoot another human.

Expand full comment
Bill Reiners's avatar

The only issue about this is in each test the officer knew what was coming. There was nothing else distracting his focus. In real life there is the unknown factors . Such as who is truly the bad guy, geography, what was the reason the officer is even there? As I was taught more space! More Safe.

Expand full comment
Alan Kerby's avatar

If you want to see how quickly and deadly a knife attack can unfold, check out the video at “The Truth About Guns” and the recent attack in Germany (https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/gun-saves-the-day-and-some-lives-in-german-knife-attack/ ).

More thoughts coming.

Expand full comment
Ken S's avatar

I am concerned by the assumption that getting two shots off before the attacker can touch the officer will equal officer survival. What was the measured target area? At the times shown, I sincerely doubt those shots are accurate enough to be effectively placed.

Expand full comment